Skip to content

A correlation function is not specified by the symbols ⟨AB⟩\langle A B\rangle alone. The state, operator order, time prescription, Fourier convention, normalization, statistics, and subtraction rule determine which physical object is being calculated.

This sheet compares the main families: ordered products describe fluctuations, commutators describe response, and time-ordered functions organize calculations. Their prefactors and units are stated explicitly so that one can translate between them.

Required background. Correlation functions introduce the physical questions; the Heisenberg picture supplies time evolution.

For a normalized density operator ρ\rho,

⟨X⟩ρ≡Tr⁡(ρX).\langle X\rangle_\rho \equiv \operatorname{Tr}(\rho X).

Real-time Heisenberg evolution under HH is

A(t)=eiHt/ℏAe−iHt/ℏ.A(t) = e^{iHt/\hbar} A e^{-iHt/\hbar}.

If

[ρ,H]=0,[\rho,H] = 0,

the state is stationary. A two-time correlator then depends only on the time difference:

⟨A(t)B(t′)⟩ρ=⟨A(t−t′)B(0)⟩ρ.\langle A(t)B(t')\rangle_\rho = \langle A(t-t')B(0)\rangle_\rho.

In a grand-canonical equilibrium state,

ρβ=e−β(H−μN)Tr⁡e−β(H−μN),\rho_\beta = \frac{ e^{-\beta(H-\mu N)} }{ \operatorname{Tr}e^{-\beta(H-\mu N)} },

stationarity under HH still holds when [H,N]=0[H,N]=0. Single-particle Green functions are also often evolved with H−μNH-\mu N so that frequencies are measured relative to μ\mu. That choice must be stated rather than inferred.

For a nonstationary state, use center and relative times,

T=t+t′2,tr=t−t′,T = \frac{t+t'}2, \qquad t_{\mathrm r} = t-t',

because a single-frequency transform in trt_{\mathrm r} does not capture the full TT dependence.

This sheet defines raw ordered products without hidden factors of ii or ℏ\hbar:

CAB>(t)≡⟨A(t)B(0)⟩,CAB<(t)≡⟨B(0)A(t)⟩.\begin{aligned} C_{AB}^{>}(t) &\equiv \langle A(t)B(0)\rangle, \\ C_{AB}^{<}(t) &\equiv \langle B(0)A(t)\rangle. \end{aligned}

For a stationary state,

CAB<(t)=CBA>(−t).C_{AB}^{<}(t) = C_{BA}^{>}(-t).

Complex conjugation gives

[CAB>(t)]∗=CA†B†<(t)=CB†A†>(−t).\begin{aligned} \left[ C_{AB}^{>}(t) \right]^* &= C_{A^\dagger B^\dagger}^{<}(t) \\ &= C_{B^\dagger A^\dagger}^{>}(-t). \end{aligned}

The greater and lesser labels refer to operator order, not numerical magnitude. They remain distinct even when AA and BB are Hermitian.

An equal-time correlator fixes both insertion times to one common value:

CAB(x,y;t)=⟨A(x,t)B(y,t)⟩.C_{AB}(\mathbf x,\mathbf y;t) = \left\langle A(\mathbf x,t) B(\mathbf y,t) \right\rangle.

Equal time does not imply:

  • equal position;
  • commuting operators;
  • connected subtraction;
  • stationarity;
  • normal ordering;
  • a probability distribution.

Common lattice examples are

Γij(1)=⟨di†dj⟩,Cnn(i,j)=⟨ninj⟩,CSSab(i,j)=⟨SiaSjb⟩,CΔ(i,j)=⟨Δi†Δj⟩.\begin{aligned} \Gamma_{ij}^{(1)} &= \langle d_i^\dagger d_j\rangle, \\ C_{nn}(i,j) &= \langle n_i n_j\rangle, \\ C_{SS}^{ab}(i,j) &= \langle S_i^a S_j^b\rangle, \\ C_{\Delta}(i,j) &= \langle\Delta_i^\dagger\Delta_j\rangle. \end{aligned}

They diagnose one-body coherence, density fluctuations, spin order, and pair coherence, respectively. The Equal-Time Correlations page explains their normalizations, contact terms, long-distance limits, and measurement interpretation.

Define fluctuation operators

δA≡A−⟨A⟩,δB≡B−⟨B⟩.\delta A \equiv A-\langle A\rangle, \qquad \delta B \equiv B-\langle B\rangle.

The connected two-point function in the displayed order is

CABc≡⟨δA δB⟩=⟨AB⟩−⟨A⟩⟨B⟩.\begin{aligned} C_{AB}^{c} &\equiv \langle\delta A\,\delta B\rangle \\ &= \langle AB\rangle - \langle A\rangle \langle B\rangle. \end{aligned}

At unequal times in a stationary state,

CABc(t)=⟨A(t)B(0)⟩−⟨A⟩⟨B⟩.C_{AB}^{c}(t) = \langle A(t)B(0)\rangle - \langle A\rangle \langle B\rangle.

Connected is not the same as symmetrized, retarded, irreducible in a diagrammatic channel, or entangled.

For a fixed three-operator order,

⟨ABC⟩c=⟨ABC⟩−⟨A⟩⟨BC⟩−⟨B⟩⟨AC⟩−⟨C⟩⟨AB⟩+2⟨A⟩⟨B⟩⟨C⟩.\langle ABC\rangle_c ={} \langle ABC\rangle - \langle A\rangle\langle BC\rangle - \langle B\rangle\langle AC\rangle - \langle C\rangle\langle AB\rangle + 2\langle A\rangle \langle B\rangle \langle C\rangle.

Higher connected functions subtract every set partition into lower moments. In noncommuting problems, the sequence and source-order convention must remain fixed. The canonical treatment is Connected Correlation Functions.

For fluctuation operators,

CABsym(t)≡12⟨{δA(t),δB(0)}⟩.C_{AB}^{\mathrm{sym}}(t) \equiv \frac12 \left\langle \left\{ \delta A(t),\delta B(0) \right\} \right\rangle.

The commutator correlator is

CABcom(t)≡⟨[A(t),B(0)]⟩.C_{AB}^{\mathrm{com}}(t) \equiv \left\langle [A(t),B(0)] \right\rangle.

Connected subtraction does not change a commutator because scalar one-point functions commute. The symmetrized correlator measures fluctuations with the two orders averaged; the commutator controls causal response. They are related at thermal equilibrium by the fluctuation–dissipation theorem, not by an identity valid in every state.

For a stationary function F(t)F(t), this page uses angular frequency:

F(ω)=∫−∞∞dt eiωtF(t),F(t)=∫−∞∞dω2π e−iωtF(ω).\begin{aligned} F(\omega) &= \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dt\, e^{i\omega t}F(t), \\ F(t) &= \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \frac{d\omega}{2\pi}\, e^{-i\omega t}F(\omega). \end{aligned}

Energy transfer is

E=ℏω.E = \hbar\omega.

Changing from a spectrum per unit angular frequency to one per unit energy introduces a Jacobian:

SE(E)=1ℏSω(E/ℏ).S_E(E) = \frac1\hbar S_\omega(E/\hbar).

This Jacobian applies to spectral densities whose integral is a weight. It does not apply to the susceptibility itself: χE(E)=χω(E/ℏ)\chi_E(E)=\chi_\omega(E/\hbar).

Adopt the source convention

Hpert(t)=−f(t)B.H_{\mathrm{pert}}(t) = -f(t)B.

The response of AA is

δ⟨A(t)⟩=∫−∞∞dt′ χABR(t−t′)f(t′).\delta\langle A(t)\rangle = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dt'\, \chi_{AB}^{\mathrm R}(t-t') f(t').

The retarded susceptibility is

χABR(t)=iℏθ(t)⟨[A(t),B(0)]⟩.\chi_{AB}^{\mathrm R}(t) = \frac{i}{\hbar} \theta(t) \left\langle [A(t),B(0)] \right\rangle.

The sign follows from the displayed minus sign in HpertH_{\mathrm{pert}}. If a source is coupled as +fB+fB, the response kernel changes sign.

Retarded means

χABR(t)=0(t<0).\chi_{AB}^{\mathrm R}(t) = 0 \qquad (t<0).

It does not mean “any correlator with a small positive imaginary part,” and it is not the same object as a positive fluctuation spectrum.

The matching advanced function is

χABA(t)=−iℏθ(−t)⟨[A(t),B(0)]⟩.\chi_{AB}^{\mathrm A}(t) = -\frac{i}{\hbar} \theta(-t) \left\langle [A(t),B(0)] \right\rangle.

It has support only for t<0t<0. The retarded–advanced difference removes the step functions:

χABR(t)−χABA(t)=iℏ⟨[A(t),B(0)]⟩.\chi_{AB}^{\mathrm R}(t) - \chi_{AB}^{\mathrm A}(t) = \frac{i}{\hbar} \left\langle [A(t),B(0)] \right\rangle.

The Retarded and Advanced Response page explains adjoint identities, half-plane analyticity, dispersion relations, stability, and source-response derivations.

Let pA,pB∈{0,1}p_A,p_B\in\{0,1\} be the fermion parities of parity-homogeneous operators. Real-time graded ordering is

TA(t)B(t′)=θ(t−t′)A(t)B(t′)+(−1)pApBθ(t′−t)×B(t′)A(t).\mathcal T A(t)B(t') ={} \theta(t-t')A(t)B(t') + (-1)^{p_Ap_B} \theta(t'-t) {}\times B(t')A(t).

The generic time-ordered expectation is

CABT(t−t′)≡⟨TA(t)B(t′)⟩.C_{AB}^{\mathrm T}(t-t') \equiv \left\langle \mathcal T A(t)B(t') \right\rangle.

For t′=0t'=0,

CABT(t)=θ(t)CAB>(t)+(−1)pApBθ(−t)CAB<(t).C_{AB}^{\mathrm T}(t) ={} \theta(t)C_{AB}^{>}(t) + (-1)^{p_Ap_B} \theta(-t)C_{AB}^{<}(t).

At t=0t=0, the value of θ(0)\theta(0) does not replace the need for one-sided limits. Canonical (anti)commutators can produce a jump or contact term.

Many-body Green functions often multiply CTC^{\mathrm T} by −i/ℏ-i/\hbar; relativistic QFT and some condensed-matter texts use different prefactors. Time ordering itself is the operator-ordering rule, not that conventional prefactor.

For canonical annihilation operators dad_a, define

η={+1,bosons,−1,fermions,\eta = \begin{cases} +1, & \text{bosons},\\ -1, & \text{fermions}, \end{cases}

and

[X,Y]η≡XY−ηYX.[X,Y]_\eta \equiv XY-\eta YX.

A common normal convention is

Gab>(t)=−iℏ⟨da(t)db†(0)⟩,Gab<(t)=−iηℏ⟨db†(0)da(t)⟩.\begin{aligned} G_{ab}^{>}(t) &= -\frac{i}{\hbar} \left\langle d_a(t)d_b^\dagger(0) \right\rangle, \\ G_{ab}^{<}(t) &= -\frac{i\eta}{\hbar} \left\langle d_b^\dagger(0)d_a(t) \right\rangle. \end{aligned}

Then

GabR(t)=θ(t)[Gab>(t)−Gab<(t)]=−iℏθ(t)⟨[da(t),db†]η⟩,\begin{aligned} G_{ab}^{\mathrm R}(t) &= \theta(t) \left[ G_{ab}^{>}(t)-G_{ab}^{<}(t) \right] \\ &= -\frac{i}{\hbar} \theta(t) \left\langle [d_a(t),d_b^\dagger]_\eta \right\rangle, \end{aligned}

and

GabA(t)=−θ(−t)[Gab>(t)−Gab<(t)]=iℏθ(−t)⟨[da(t),db†]η⟩.\begin{aligned} G_{ab}^{\mathrm A}(t) &= -\theta(-t) \left[ G_{ab}^{>}(t)-G_{ab}^{<}(t) \right] \\ &= \frac{i}{\hbar} \theta(-t) \left\langle [d_a(t),d_b^\dagger]_\eta \right\rangle. \end{aligned}

These single-particle retarded functions use a statistics-dependent bracket and a conventional −i/ℏ-i/\hbar prefactor. They should not be substituted into the observable-response formula without checking the channel and source convention. Green Functions in Many-Body QM develops the full family.

Let

K=H−μN,Lτ=βℏ.\mathcal K = H-\mu N, \qquad L_\tau = \beta\hbar.

Imaginary-time evolution is

A(τ)=eτK/ℏAe−τK/ℏ.A(\tau) = e^{\tau\mathcal K/\hbar} A e^{-\tau\mathcal K/\hbar}.

Graded imaginary-time ordering is

TτA(τ)B(τ′)=θ(τ−τ′)A(τ)B(τ′)+(−1)pApBθ(τ′−τ)×B(τ′)A(τ).\mathcal T_\tau A(\tau)B(\tau') ={} \theta(\tau-\tau')A(\tau)B(\tau') + (-1)^{p_Ap_B} \theta(\tau'-\tau) {}\times B(\tau')A(\tau).

A channel-dependent convention is

CAB(τ−τ′)≡sAB⟨TτA(τ)B(τ′)⟩β.\mathcal C_{AB}(\tau-\tau') \equiv s_{AB} \left\langle \mathcal T_\tau A(\tau)B(\tau') \right\rangle_\beta.

The fixed sign sABs_{AB} is a definition. The exchange sign (−1)pApB(-1)^{p_Ap_B} follows from fermion parity. For example:

  • a normal fermion propagator often uses sAB=−1s_{AB}=-1;
  • a normal boson propagator also often uses sAB=−1s_{AB}=-1;
  • a density or coordinate correlator often uses sAB=+1s_{AB}=+1.

For a two-point function whose transported insertion has fermion parity pp,

Cp(τ+Lτ)=(−1)pCp(τ).\mathcal C_p(\tau+L_\tau) = (-1)^p \mathcal C_p(\tau).

These boundary conditions use the full grand-canonical Fock-space trace and evolution with K\mathcal K. In a fixed-NN trace they hold for sector-preserving observables, but cannot simply be applied to number-changing fields: cycling such a field through the sector projector changes the sector.

Using Matsubara energies ζn\zeta_n,

C(iζn)=1ℏ∫0βℏdτ eiζnτ/ℏC(τ),C(τ)=1β∑ne−iζnτ/ℏC(iζn).\begin{aligned} \mathcal C(i\zeta_n) &= \frac1\hbar \int_0^{\beta\hbar} d\tau\, e^{i\zeta_n\tau/\hbar} \mathcal C(\tau), \\ \mathcal C(\tau) &= \frac1\beta \sum_n e^{-i\zeta_n\tau/\hbar} \mathcal C(i\zeta_n). \end{aligned}

The allowed grids are

ζnB=2πnβ,ζnF=(2n+1)πβ.\begin{aligned} \zeta_n^{\mathrm B} &= \frac{2\pi n}{\beta}, \\ \zeta_n^{\mathrm F} &= \frac{(2n+1)\pi}{\beta}. \end{aligned}

The corresponding angular frequencies are ωn=ζn/ℏ\omega_n=\zeta_n/\hbar. The canonical Bosonic and Fermionic Matsubara Frequencies page explains indexing, cutoff, and summation details.

Analytic continuation is not justified by replacing iζni\zeta_n with E+i0E+i0 in an arbitrary fitted formula. A spectral representation and control of static bosonic terms are required.

The word spectral is overloaded:

Object Defining ingredient Typical sign property
ordered transition spectrum Fourier transform of ⟨A(t)B(0)⟩\langle A(t)B(0)\rangle nonnegative for B=A†B=A^\dagger
response spectral density Fourier transform of a commutator generally signed
single-particle spectral function retarded–advanced discontinuity of GG positive semidefinite in standard fermionic channels
dynamic structure factor momentum-resolved ordered spectrum nonnegative in a conjugate channel
density of states trace or momentum sum of a single-particle spectrum nonnegative in standard use
measured intensity probe and detector forward model nonnegative counts, but not a universal correlator

The formulas below use compatible conventions, but their units still differ.

Define

SAB(ω)≡12π∫−∞∞dt eiωtCAB>(t).\mathcal S_{AB}(\omega) \equiv \frac1{2\pi} \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dt\, e^{i\omega t} C_{AB}^{>}(t).

Let

ρ=∑npn∣n⟩⟨n∣,H∣n⟩=En∣n⟩.\rho = \sum_n p_n \lvert n\rangle\langle n\rvert, \qquad H\lvert n\rangle = E_n\lvert n\rangle.

With Anm=⟨n∣A∣m⟩A_{nm}=\langle n\lvert A\rvert m\rangle and Bmn=⟨m∣B∣n⟩B_{mn}=\langle m\lvert B\rvert n\rangle,

SAB(ω)=∑n,mpnAnmBmn×δ ⁣(ω−Em−Enℏ).\mathcal S_{AB}(\omega) ={} \sum_{n,m} p_n A_{nm}B_{mn} \times \delta\!\left( \omega-\frac{E_m-E_n}{\hbar} \right).

If B=A†B=A^\dagger,

SAA†(ω)≥0\mathcal S_{AA^\dagger}(\omega) \ge 0

as a spectral measure. Its zeroth moment is the equal-time ordered correlator:

∫−∞∞dω SAB(ω)=⟨AB⟩.\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} d\omega\, \mathcal S_{AB}(\omega) = \langle AB\rangle.

For a Gibbs state with the same generator used in the time evolution, detailed balance is

SBA(−ω)=e−βℏωSAB(ω).\mathcal S_{BA}(-\omega) = e^{-\beta\hbar\omega} \mathcal S_{AB}(\omega).

This compares reversed order and frequency. In a grand-canonical state with HH evolution it applies as written to number-conserving channels; number-changing channels require chemical-work factors, or K=H−μN\mathcal K=H-\mu N evolution with energy measured accordingly. One arbitrary cross-spectrum need not be even or positive.

For the observable response convention above, define

ρAB(ω)≡12πℏ∫−∞∞dt eiωt×⟨[A(t),B(0)]⟩.\rho_{AB}(\omega) \equiv{} \frac{1}{2\pi\hbar} \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dt\, e^{i\omega t} \times \left\langle [A(t),B(0)] \right\rangle.

It is the difference of ordered spectra:

ρAB(ω)=1ℏ[SAB(ω)−SBA(−ω)].\rho_{AB}(\omega) = \frac1\hbar \left[ \mathcal S_{AB}(\omega) - \mathcal S_{BA}(-\omega) \right].

The retarded–advanced discontinuity is

χABR(ω)−χABA(ω)=2πi ρAB(ω).\chi_{AB}^{\mathrm R}(\omega) - \chi_{AB}^{\mathrm A}(\omega) = 2\pi i\, \rho_{AB}(\omega).

For a conjugate Hermitian equilibrium channel in this sign convention,

Im⁡χAAR(ω)=πρAA(ω).\operatorname{Im} \chi_{AA}^{\mathrm R}(\omega) = \pi\rho_{AA}(\omega).

Detailed balance gives the equilibrium preview

ρAB(ω)=1−e−βℏωℏSAB(ω).\rho_{AB}(\omega) = \frac{ 1-e^{-\beta\hbar\omega} }{\hbar} \mathcal S_{AB}(\omega).

For a matrix of Hermitian observable channels, the general absorptive part is χ′′=(χR−χA)/(2i)=πρ\boldsymbol\chi''=(\boldsymbol\chi^{\mathrm R}-\boldsymbol\chi^{\mathrm A})/(2i)=\pi\boldsymbol\rho, not the elementwise imaginary part. Also, any exactly zero-frequency fluctuation weight disappears from the commutator spectrum. It must be kept separately when reconstructing static fluctuations; dividing by 1−e−βℏω1-e^{-\beta\hbar\omega} cannot recover it.

The Fluctuation–Dissipation Theorem derives the conversion to symmetrized spectra and the zero-frequency limit.

With GR(E)=∫dt eiEt/ℏGR(t)G^{\mathrm R}(E)=\int dt\,e^{iEt/\hbar}G^{\mathrm R}(t) and the earlier −i/ℏ-i/\hbar time prefactor, define the normal fermionic spectral density per unit energy:

Aab(E)≡i2π[GabR(E)−GabA(E)].A_{ab}(E) \equiv \frac{i}{2\pi} \left[ G_{ab}^{\mathrm R}(E) - G_{ab}^{\mathrm A}(E) \right].

For a diagonal channel,

Aaa(E)=−1πIm⁡GaaR(E).A_{aa}(E) = -\frac1\pi \operatorname{Im} G_{aa}^{\mathrm R}(E).

Canonical anticommutation gives

∫−∞∞dE Aaa(E)=1\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dE\, A_{aa}(E) = 1

for a complete normalized orbital. This positive single-particle spectrum is not the signed response density ρAB\rho_{AB}, even though both are retarded–advanced discontinuities.

For a Hermitian lattice operator OjO_j, define

Oq≡∑j=1Le−iq⋅rjOj.O_{\mathbf q} \equiv \sum_{j=1}^{L} e^{-i\mathbf q\cdot\mathbf r_j} O_j.

With

δOq≡Oq−⟨Oq⟩,\delta O_{\mathbf q} \equiv O_{\mathbf q} - \langle O_{\mathbf q}\rangle,

one connected static convention is

SOc(q)≡1L⟨δOqδO−q⟩.S_O^c(\mathbf q) \equiv \frac1L \left\langle \delta O_{\mathbf q} \delta O_{-\mathbf q} \right\rangle.

For O−q=Oq†O_{-\mathbf q}=O_{\mathbf q}^\dagger,

SOc(q)≥0.S_O^c(\mathbf q) \ge 0.

At q=0\mathbf q=0, a density structure factor measures total-number fluctuations under this normalization. It vanishes in an exact fixed-number state but need not vanish in a grand-canonical ensemble.

A compatible angular-frequency convention is

SOc(q,ω)≡12πL∫−∞∞dt eiωt×⟨δOq(t)δO−q(0)⟩.S_O^c(\mathbf q,\omega) \equiv{} \frac1{2\pi L} \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dt\, e^{i\omega t} \times \left\langle \delta O_{\mathbf q}(t) \delta O_{-\mathbf q}(0) \right\rangle.

Its zeroth-moment relation is

∫−∞∞dω SOc(q,ω)=SOc(q).\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} d\omega\, S_O^c(\mathbf q,\omega) = S_O^c(\mathbf q).

The factor 1/L1/L, the sign in OqO_{\mathbf q}, and the factor 1/(2π)1/(2\pi) vary across disciplines. Scattering cross sections also include probe form factors, polarization tensors, kinematic prefactors, resolution, and background. The canonical home is Structure Factors.

With internal indices, a spectrum is a matrix:

S(ω)=[Sab(ω)].\mathbf S(\omega) = \left[ S_{ab}(\omega) \right].

Positivity means

v†S(ω)v≥0\mathbf v^\dagger \mathbf S(\omega) \mathbf v \ge 0

for every vector v\mathbf v in a conjugate ordered channel. It does not require each off-diagonal entry to be real or positive.

Hermiticity, reciprocity, time reversal, inversion, and point-group symmetry impose different index and momentum relations. Apply only the symmetries actually possessed by the state, Hamiltonian, operators, and boundary conditions.

For canonical modes,

⟨aiaj†⟩=δij+⟨aj†ai⟩,⟨cicj†⟩=δij−⟨cj†ci⟩.\begin{aligned} \langle a_i a_j^\dagger\rangle &= \delta_{ij} + \langle a_j^\dagger a_i\rangle, \\ \langle c_i c_j^\dagger\rangle &= \delta_{ij} - \langle c_j^\dagger c_i\rangle. \end{aligned}

These relations fix jumps in one-sided single-particle Green functions. In a continuum,

δij⟶δ(d)(x−y),\delta_{ij} \longrightarrow \delta^{(d)}(\mathbf x-\mathbf y),

so coincident-point expressions can be distributional or ultraviolet divergent. Normal ordering removes specified contractions; it is not a universal instruction to discard every contact term.

Channel Operators Typical object
density δnq\delta n_{\mathbf q}, δn−q\delta n_{-\mathbf q} structure factor and density response
spin SqaS_{\mathbf q}^a, S−qbS_{-\mathbf q}^b magnetic structure factor and susceptibility
current JaJ^a, JbJ^b conductivity kernel with possible contact term
single particle dkd_{\mathbf k}, dk†d_{\mathbf k}^\dagger Green function and addition/removal spectrum
pair Δq\Delta_{\mathbf q}, Δq†\Delta_{\mathbf q}^\dagger pair susceptibility and coherence
order parameter δOq\delta O_{\mathbf q}, δO−q\delta O_{-\mathbf q} static scaling and collective spectrum

The same operator pair can generate a raw correlator, response, Matsubara function, or structure factor. The time prescription and normalization select the physical question.

  • Static limit: lim⁡ω→0χ(q,ω)\lim_{\omega\to0}\chi(\mathbf q,\omega) can depend on whether q→0\mathbf q\to0 is taken first.
  • Equal-time limit: t→0+t\to0^+ and t→0−t\to0^- can differ by a canonical contact term.
  • Analytic continuation: finite Matsubara data do not determine a stable real-frequency spectrum without additional information.
  • Thermodynamic limit: finite systems have discrete lines and recurrences; continua and irreversible widths emerge only after appropriate limits or coupling to an environment.
  • Connected subtraction: removing ⟨A⟩⟨B⟩\langle A\rangle\langle B\rangle eliminates a zero-frequency elastic piece only when the state is stationary and the normalization is matched.
  • Broadening: replacing δ\delta functions by Lorentzians or Gaussians is a visualization or physical-resolution model, not an exact identity.
  • Energy origin: number-changing spectra shift when evolution changes between HH and H−μNH-\mu N.

1. Show shift invariance of a connected correlator

Section titled “1. Show shift invariance of a connected correlator”

Let A′=A+aIA'=A+aI and B′=B+bIB'=B+bI. Show that

⟨A′B′⟩c=⟨AB⟩c.\langle A'B'\rangle_c = \langle AB\rangle_c.
Solution

The shifted fluctuation operators are

δA′=A+aI−⟨A+aI⟩=A−⟨A⟩=δA,δB′=δB.\begin{aligned} \delta A' &= A+aI-\langle A+aI\rangle \\ &= A-\langle A\rangle = \delta A, \\ \delta B' &= \delta B. \end{aligned}

Therefore

⟨A′B′⟩c=⟨δA′δB′⟩=⟨δA δB⟩=⟨AB⟩c.\begin{aligned} \langle A'B'\rangle_c &= \langle\delta A'\delta B'\rangle \\ &= \langle\delta A\,\delta B\rangle \\ &= \langle AB\rangle_c. \end{aligned}

Connected two-point functions are insensitive to additive scalar offsets.

In a stationary state, prove

CAB<(t)=CBA>(−t).C_{AB}^{<}(t) = C_{BA}^{>}(-t).

Then write the time-ordered correlator for two odd fermionic operators.

Solution

By definition,

CBA>(−t)=⟨B(−t)A(0)⟩.C_{BA}^{>}(-t) = \langle B(-t)A(0)\rangle.

Stationarity allows both times to be shifted by tt:

⟨B(−t)A(0)⟩=⟨B(0)A(t)⟩=CAB<(t).\begin{aligned} \langle B(-t)A(0)\rangle &= \langle B(0)A(t)\rangle \\ &= C_{AB}^{<}(t). \end{aligned}

If pA=pB=1p_A=p_B=1, exchanging the operators under time ordering contributes a minus sign:

CABT(t)=θ(t)CAB>(t)−θ(−t)CAB<(t).C_{AB}^{\mathrm T}(t) ={} \theta(t)C_{AB}^{>}(t) - \theta(-t)C_{AB}^{<}(t).

Use the Lehmann representation to show that SAA†(ω)\mathcal S_{AA^\dagger}(\omega) is nonnegative and that its integral equals ⟨AA†⟩\langle AA^\dagger\rangle.

Solution

Set B=A†B=A^\dagger in the ordered spectrum:

SAA†(ω)=∑n,mpn∣Anm∣2×δ ⁣(ω−Em−Enℏ).\mathcal S_{AA^\dagger}(\omega) ={} \sum_{n,m} p_n |A_{nm}|^2 \times \delta\!\left( \omega-\frac{E_m-E_n}{\hbar} \right).

Every pnp_n and ∣Anm∣2|A_{nm}|^2 is nonnegative, so the spectral measure is nonnegative.

Integrating over frequency removes the delta function:

∫dω SAA†(ω)=∑n,mpn∣Anm∣2=∑npn⟨n∣AA†∣n⟩=⟨AA†⟩.\begin{aligned} \int d\omega\, \mathcal S_{AA^\dagger}(\omega) &= \sum_{n,m} p_n|A_{nm}|^2 \\ &= \sum_n p_n \langle n|AA^\dagger|n\rangle \\ &= \langle AA^\dagger\rangle. \end{aligned}

Show that the dynamic definition on this page satisfies

∫dω SOc(q,ω)=SOc(q).\int d\omega\, S_O^c(\mathbf q,\omega) = S_O^c(\mathbf q).
Solution

Insert the dynamic definition and use

∫−∞∞dω2πeiωt=δ(t).\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \frac{d\omega}{2\pi} e^{i\omega t} = \delta(t).

Then

∫dω SOc(q,ω)=1L∫dt δ(t)×⟨δOq(t)δO−q(0)⟩=1L⟨δOqδO−q⟩=SOc(q).\begin{aligned} \int d\omega\, S_O^c(\mathbf q,\omega) &= \frac1L \int dt\, \delta(t) \times \left\langle \delta O_{\mathbf q}(t) \delta O_{-\mathbf q}(0) \right\rangle \\ &= \frac1L \left\langle \delta O_{\mathbf q} \delta O_{-\mathbf q} \right\rangle \\ &= S_O^c(\mathbf q). \end{aligned}
  • A. L. Fetter and J. D. Walecka, Quantum Theory of Many-Particle Systems, Dover (2003) — Lehmann representations, propagators, response, and sum rules.
  • R. Kubo, “Statistical-Mechanical Theory of Irreversible Processes. I”, Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 12, 570–586 (1957) — linear response and fluctuation relations.
  • S. W. Lovesey, Theory of Neutron Scattering from Condensed Matter, Vol. 1, Clarendon Press (1984) — structure factors, response channels, and experimental normalization.
  • G. D. Mahan, Many-Particle Physics, 3rd ed., Springer (2000) — real-time Green functions, response, spectral functions, and many-body conventions.
  • P. C. Martin and J. Schwinger, “Theory of Many-Particle Systems. I”, Physical Review 115, 1342–1373 (1959) — equilibrium Green-function hierarchy and thermal boundary relations.
  • J. W. Negele and H. Orland, Quantum Many-Particle Systems, Westview Press (1998) — imaginary-time functions, Matsubara transforms, and functional methods.
  • L. Van Hove, “Correlations in Space and Time and Born Approximation Scattering in Systems of Interacting Particles”, Physical Review 95, 249–262 (1954) — dynamic correlations and scattering.